Featured Stories
-
The Past, Present and Future of Corrugated Die Cutting
Die cutting has long been a cornerstone in package manufacturing, playing a pivotal role in producing boxes efficiently and accurately. -
Innovating Safety Child-Resistant Stand-Up Pouches that Meet Sustainability Goals
In the past, brands sometimes had to choose between child-resistant packaging features and sustainability. -
Ultrasonic Drying of Biodegradable Molded Recycled Paper
This first of a three-part series will discuss a test program conducted by Heat Technologies, Inc.'s Spectra HE UltraTM drying system
News | New Products
-
Eagle Flexible Packaging, Inc. Acquires State-of-the-Art SOMA Optima2 Wide Web Flexographic Printing Press
Eagle Flexible Packaging, Inc. (Eagle), a leader in the flexible packaging industry, proudly announces the acquisition of a SOMA Optima2
-
Insignia Die-Cutting Series Wins PRINTING United Alliance 2024 Pinnacle Product Award for Die-Cutting Equipment
Rollem International has announced the Insignia Die-Cutting Series received a coveted PRINTING United Alliance 2024 Pinnacle Award for Die-Cutting Equipment.
-
NIRI Strengthens Fiber, Filament, Fabric Extrusion Capabilities with Appointment of Dr. Javier Vera Sorroche
Dr. Javier Vera Sorroche will lead NIRI’s extrusion research and development capability.
-
Take a New Approach to ESD Packaging for Electronics
In the world of electronics manufacturing, ESD managers have the critical role of ensuring that components do not get damaged by electrostatic discharge (ESD).
-
TAPPI/AICC Announce Cris Carter to Keynote at SuperCorrExpo® 2024
TAPPI and AICC, co-producers of the mega corrugated event SuperCorrExpo® 2024
-
E&R Specifies Vetaphone for Innovation & Application Centre
Founded in 1918 and renowned for expertise in the design of sophisticated laboratory scale and pilot production machinery
-
Winpak's Zero-error Approach Reshapes Packaging
With a 47-year history of success, Winpak recognized the intricate nature of packaging printing, particularly when handling dense information for product labeling.
Expert Advice
Supreme Court Decision Gives Employers Leeway in ADA
- Published: August 01, 2002, By Sheila A. Millar, Attorney-at-Law, Keller & Heckman, Washington, DC
In the third of recent, important decisions involving the Americans with Disability Act (ADA), the US Supreme Court unanimously ruled the ADA allows an employer to refuse to hire a person with a disability where that disability poses a direct threat to the individual when performing a job. The case is Chevron USA Inc. v. Echazabal.
Decisions addressing the scope of the ADA are critically important to converters, suppliers, and their customers, whose facilities may involve exposure to chemicals or other materials potentially harmful to individuals with certain medical conditions, or whose disabilities may impair their ability to do a job safely.
The facts of the case decided by the high court are as follows: The employee, Mario Echazabal, worked for a contractor of Chevron USA Inc. In 1996 Mr. Echazabal applied for employment directly with Chevron. The oil giant offered Mr. Echazabal employment, conditioned upon successfully completing a medical exam. The testing physician found liver damage and said continued exposure to toxins at the Chevron facility would lead to further liver damage.
Chevron withdrew its offer of employment to Mr. Echazabal and informed the contractor, Mr. Echazabal's employer, either to reassign him to a job that would not involve exposure to potentially damaging toxins or to remove him from the refinery. The contractor laid off Mr. Echazabal, and he filed suit against Chevron, alleging it violated the ADA.
The Supreme Court ruled an employer may refuse to hire an individual if, based on a reasonable medical judgment regarding that individual's medical condition, his disability would create or aggravate a danger to his own safety or health on the job.
Moreover, the Court noted, the Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA) requires an employer to actively ensure it provides a safe and healthful workplace. If Chevron were required under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to hire persons like Mr. Echazabal, then compliance with OSHA would conflict with the ADA, a result at odds with workplace safety objectives.
The unanimity of the decision is an especially important factor, suggesting rare agreement on the fundamental principle that employers may take into consideration a prospective employee's medical condition in determining the appropriateness of employment.
What should converters do?
A converter, supplier, or customer may require employees to meet physical and medical criteria, and may set those requirements as conditions upon which employment offers are made. However, those criteria must be applied to an individual based on a reasonable medical judgment of that individual.
Arguably, the ADA requires an employer to reassign an individual such as Mr. Echazabal to a position that would not endanger his safety or health, provided doing so would not be an undue burden. If no other job is available, an employer may refuse to hire that employee.
The Court addressed a number of important issues not discussed here; ADA requirements and the Chevron case's assessment of them involve complex issues. Members of the converting industry should be sure to review carefully hiring and accommodation decisions with experienced labor specialists to be sure they are adhering to the applicable requirements.
Sheila A. Millar, a partner with Keller and Heckman LLP, counsels both corporate and association clients. Contact her at 202/434-4143; This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.; PackagingLaw.com